Required field “Mr./Ms.”: Ensuring politeness doesn’t become a data protection violation

A “Dear Ms. Smith” is considered as the gold standard of cultivated customer communication. However, in its January 9, 2025, ruling (C-394/23 – “Mousse”), the ECJ clarified that a business may not require customers to provide their title and gender simply to make the communication seem more personal.

The case: A French railway company required users to choose between “Monsieur” and “Madame” when purchasing tickets online. The organisation Mousse, which campaigns against discrimination, lodged a complaint about this with the French data protection authority CNIL, and the matter eventually reached the ECJ via the French Council of State.

What the European Court of Justice ruled

  • Contract performance: The collection of title and gender data for the purpose of gender-specific personalisation of communication is generally neither objectively essential nor necessary for a contract (art. 6(1)(b) GDPR). The main service can be provided without it.
  • Legitimate interest as a legal basis also generally fails (art. 6(1)(f) GDPR). Anyone who fails to inform customers of the pursued interest at the time of collection (art. 13(1)(d) GDPR) cannot invoke it from the outset. And if an equally effective, less intrusive means is available – one that is gender-neutral and includes polite forms of address – the requirement of necessity is not met.
  • No rescue anchor in objection: Whether data subjects could object under art. 21 of the GDPR is irrelevant to the requirement of necessity.
  • Data minimisation standard: “It’s just the way it is” is not a convincing argument – social conventions are irrelevant. Even a genuine need, such as sleeper carriages reserved for people of the same gender identity or support services, justifies data collection only for the customers it actually affects, not across the whole customer base.

Our recommendations for practice

  1. Correct past data: Do not continue to use old customer data containing enforced titles for personalised communication; instead, clean up the data
  2. Avoid: Making title or gender fields mandatory – in forms, ordering processes, and contracts.
  3. Permitted: Use a gender-neutral salutation (“Hello, first name surname”) as the default, with the title field as an optional field.